American Idol S07E11 S07E12: Top 24: 1960s


AI season 7 episodes 11 and 12.

Since I went 12 for 12 in American Idol last year, I will blog again this year. As long as Idol is good and blogging is fun.

In the spirit of The Four Word Film Review, I give you my four-word Idol reviews.

1. David Hernandez – Too much affectation. Stiff.
2. Chikezie – Slow start, strong finish.
3. David Cook – Doing The Turtles proud.
4. Jason Yeager – Don't sing Moon River.
5. Robbie Carrico – Good recording studio voice.
6. David Archuleta – Phenom makes top 20.
7. Danny Noriega – Don't do Elvis karaoke.
8. Luke Menard – Ballad? Danger, Will Robinson!
9. Colton Berry – Student wins teen voters.
10. Garrett Haley – Sung convincingly with hair.
11. Jason Castro – Drummer strums memorable Daydream.
12. Michael Johns – Aussie sings Doors convincingly.

Worst male performances:
1. David Hernandez
4. Jason Yeager
7. Danny Noriega
8. Luke Menard

Botton 2 men:
1. David Hernandez
4. Jason Yeager

1. Kristy Lee Cook – On key but forgettable.
2. Joanne Borgella – Off key and painful.
3. Alaina Whitaker – Can't hit high notes.
4. Amanda Overmyer – Sing more, scat less.
5. Amy Davis – Painful sappy off-key ballad.
6. Brooke White – Good but not great.
7. Alexandréa Lushington – Wow! Best so far!
8. Kady Malloy – Boring cruise ship ballad.
9. Asia'h Epperson – Janice no, vocal yes.
10. Ramiele Malubay – Little girl, big voice.
11. Syesha Mercado – Blues rock sung unconvincingly.
12. Carly Smithson – Powerful, controlled, but Broadway-like.

Worse female performances:
1. Kristy Lee Cook
2. Joanne Borgella
5. Amy Davis
8. Kady Malloy

Bottom 2 women:
2. Joanne Borgella
5. Amy Davis

See also:
http://idolingalong.blogspot.com/2008/02/12-guys-10-spots-hey-you-dont-suck.html
http://www.variousandsundry.com/2008/02/19/ai7-round-of-24-boys/
http://www.variousandsundry.com/2008/02/20/ai7-round-of-24-girls/

One Reply to “American Idol S07E11 S07E12: Top 24: 1960s”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *